Home » community of practice » Reflections

Reflections

Like many research students, one of my concerns is the need for some kind of originality in the work I am undertaking. I am still unsure exactly what that means – and how much originality is necessary – but it seems to relate to various different things.

It could be originality of method – not so much inventing a new methodology as using existing methodologies in different ways.

It could be exploring an area which hasn’t been explored before.

It could be exploring an area which has been explored before but from a different perspective.

It could be bringing a range of ideas from different areas together and looking at how they interconnect and may provide a different way of looking at an area.

The more I read about my area of interest – the learning journeys of those involved in caring for and supporting children and young people on the autistic spectrum – the more work I realise has already been done. I also realise that much of this work has been done from very specific perspectives: the support needs of parents following diagnosis; the parent as advocate; the continued professional development of teachers or doctors or social workers; the role of electronic media in informing patients. Although partnership is a theme – partnership between parents and professionals in various settings – it is unclear how much this is a reality most of the time, although there is a fair bit about the advocacy role of parents.

One of the possible areas of interest is the contrast between the formal processes and the informal processes, for example what the code of practice says should happen and what happens in practice – and why don’t the two match up. Another area is the whole question of whether there is an autistic spectrum community of practice. If it exists, where does it exist and in what form? Or is it a number of discrete areas of expertise in which some participants are able to act as gatekeepers giving access to their area of expertise, or infiltrators gaining knowledge of another area.

Looking at learning journeys is about the various ways in which people learn about the spectrum. Knowing that there is a mix of formal, informal and serendipitous probably doesn’t tell us much of itself, but when this is applied to the outputs of the domain, i.e. the services, resources, support, etc, and the decision making processes, life gets very interesting.

Advertisements

1 Comment

  1. katharinejewitt says:

    Hi Liz, interesting post and one I’ve been thinking about a lot recently too. I’ve found it quite depressing to discover more and more people who’ve done the same thing! I console myself in thinking that there is the aim that the research will contribute something new to the knowledge. There’s an interesting chapter on originality in Denscombe’s book http://katharinejewittblog.wordpress.com/2010/05/15/ground-rules-for-good-research/ also chapter 5 of Doing qualitative research: a practical handbook By David Silverman
    Another interesting view of this is in Pat Cryer’s the research student’s guide to success (open university press) chapters 15-17.
    Cryer uses the anaology of the expedition to suggest different senses of ‘original research’ – ‘the research student is the explorer and the expedition is the research programme’ (1996,p.145) and Cryer discusses
    originality in tools, techniques and procedures; exploring the unknown; exploring the unanticipated; orginality in use of data; in outcomes; in by products.
    I think that it is quite interesting to keep reviewing our research against Cryer’s definition of originality.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: